South Korea Falls for Elderly American Boy Band’s Insurance Songs
PART D sells out Seoul in nine minutes with songs about prior authorization, hold music and a knee pending since March.
SEOUL—Praising a deadpan delivery unlike anything in domestic pop, sources confirmed Thursday that South Korea has fallen for PART D, a five-member boy band of elderly American men whose songs consist entirely of grievances about their joints, their insurers, their marriages, and other people in general.
The group, whose members range in age from 71 to 83, sold out Seoul’s Gocheok Sky Dome in nine minutes on the strength of its debut single, “This Is Not A Bill.” The title comes from the explanation of benefits, a statement American insurers mail after a medical visit that lists what was charged and carries those five words across the top. In the first verse, leader Dale Hutchins, 74, a retired heating and cooling estimator from Sandusky, OH, reads his aloud over a drum machine. In the second, he reads the letter denying coverage for his left knee.
“When he reaches ‘you may owe four hundred twelve dollars and sixty-one cents,’ sixteen thousand people say it with him,” said fan Kim Seo-yeon, 19, raising the group’s official light stick, the glowing wand K-pop fans wave in unison, which in PART D’s case is an illuminated seven-day pill organizer. “American humor is so dry. He looks truly upset.”
Hutchins, reached backstage with his left leg elevated, confirmed that he is. “I don’t know what they’re laughing at,” he said. “The second verse is the letter. I read them the letter. My knee has been pending since March.”
The album’s centerpiece, “Hold (Your Call Is Important To Us),” runs 38 minutes and consists of instrumental music over which Hutchins says the word “representative” nine times at irregular intervals. Audiences have memorized the timing and shout it with him.
PART D takes its name from the portion of Medicare, the federal insurance program for Americans 65 and older, that covers prescription drugs. The group was assembled by Lakeshore Senior Entertainment Group of Lakeland, FL, which scouted its members in pharmacy pickup lines and trained them for six years. Korean labels commonly bar their young performers from dating, and Lakeshore’s contract goes further, prohibiting “involvement with another person in any degree,” a clause all five men reportedly signed before the lawyer had finished reading it aloud. The clause inspired the group’s biggest ballad, “In Any Degree,” in which Hutchins renounces romance, marriage, joint ownership of a riding mower, and eye contact with a neighbor across a cul-de-sac.
The lineup follows K-pop tradition. Earl Tidwell, 83, serves as the “visual,” the member chosen for looks, a title he said he inherited when lead dancer Leonard Vogel, 77, “got the neck thing.” Gary Pruitt, 71, is the maknae, the Korean term for a group’s youngest member, and is regarded by the others as a kid who still believes the insurer will reverse itself on appeal.
Fans call themselves Beneficiaries, Medicare’s word for the people it covers, and speak with open envy of the elder care the songs describe. Their favorite feature is prior authorization, the American practice in which an insurer must approve a treatment before a patient may receive it.
“In America, when an old man’s knee hurts, a company assigns people to think about it for eleven weeks before anyone may touch him,” said Park Min-jae, 18. “In Korea, I walk into a clinic, I pay a few thousand won, and it is finished in ten minutes. Nobody writes to me afterward. Nobody has ever asked me to hold.”
According to the Seoul Institute for Imported Sentiment, 64 percent of South Koreans under 25 who heard the album telephoned the National Health Insurance Service within a week, and most reported disappointment when the matter was resolved in under four minutes. A further 11 percent mailed themselves a letter. Three asked a parent to deny them something in writing.
The enthusiasm reached the National Assembly on Thursday, where lawmakers voted 212–61 to pass the Dignified Waiting Act, which requires that every caller over 65 be placed on hold for a minimum of 38 minutes. A pilot program in Daejeon will require 4,000 seniors to request written permission for care they are already guaranteed. “Permission will be granted in every case,” the Ministry of Health and Welfare said in a statement. “We ask only that our elders be allowed eleven weeks of not knowing.”
Dr. Han Ji-won of the Korea Institute for Comparative Coverage Studies testified against the bill. “South Korea has had universal health insurance since 1989,” Han told the committee. “The song you love is a man asking a stranger’s permission to have an MRI.” Members thanked Han for her testimony and asked whether she could get the album signed.
At press time, 14,000 Beneficiaries had gathered outside Hutchins’ hotel with banners reading “WE WILL APPEAL” after learning that his claim had been denied a second time.
Opinion: I Am The Woman In ‘Forty-One Years (She Chews Like That),’ And I Would Like To Add Some Context
By Carol Hutchins
Last week, 16,000 South Korean teenagers sang, in unison and in English, a description of the way I eat a Triscuit. I am told it was the loudest moment of the concert. I am told some of them wept.
I have been married to Dale for 41 years, and the song is accurate. I do chew like that. I have chewed like that since the Reagan administration, and Dale has raised the matter, by my estimate, on 9,000 occasions, every one of them in our kitchen, unaccompanied. I did not anticipate that the 9,001st would chart.
The young women who write to me, in lovely English, on stationery printed with a cartoon pill organizer, want to know what it is like to be loved by a man who notices so much. Dale’s noticing is selective. Our 30th anniversary passed unobserved. So did the downstairs hallway, which has been green for six years. Chewing, he catches.
They also ask about the healthcare. A girl named Seo-yeon wanted to know whether it is true that a company watches over Dale’s knee. In a sense, yes. I told her I have spent 31 hours on the telephone on behalf of that knee since March, and she wrote back that it was the most romantic thing she had ever heard. I let it stand. I am 72, and it was nice to hear.
As for “In Any Degree,” Dale sings that he wants no involvement with another person in any degree, and he sings it very well. Then he comes offstage and asks me where his other shoe is. I know where it is. I have always known where it is.
My one request is that verse three, which concerns my sister, be removed from the Japanese release.
Carol Hutchins is a retired dental hygienist who has been involved with another person to a considerable degree since 1985.
- #health-insurance
- #medicare
- #k-pop
- #south-korea
More Politics
All Politics
PoliticsPolitical Science: When Logic Takes a Holiday
Democrats agree they are NPCs after weeks of gaslighting, and say it explains a lot about this timeline.
PoliticsSpeaker Johnson Finds 217 Is Bigger Than 218 for Epstein Petition
Math works differently when the petition is about Epstein, the Speaker explains.
PoliticsClimate Working Group Accidentally Discovers Peer Review
A federal climate panel tries to beat the science and accidentally invents peer review.